This is the third week running for the nationwide teachers’ strike. I am neither a student nor a parent at this juncture; but at least I’m a relative, a neighbor or so to say to either. But in my life I have experienced a situation like the one parents and students are experiencing, actually during a similar season. The teachers’ strike of 1998 brought about happenings that have been prettily nailed in our memories; thanks to the Kenya National Union of Teachers. Those who followed the situation closely can remember that in that time the security men were asked to extend their role to the examination rooms courtesy of the Kenya Certificate of Secondary Examination. Rather funny or isn’t it? Reminds me of the saying that exits the cat, enter the mouse.
The whole episode brought about quite some interesting scenes. Or how does it seem to you when you imagine a policeman moving in, out and around an examination room with a loaded gun? And do you even wonder how the armed fellows would handle a case of cheating in an exam? I dare they would not even distinguish between genuine students and exam cheats. But it is customary to imagine that if by any chance they were sure that actually there was cheating in the exam, they would shoot in the air and fire tear gas canisters to disperse the cheats or better still make them forfeit the cheating materials. And then their inspector would report to the press, “We got a tip off that some students were cheating in the exam. My boys acted very fast and they shot in the air and the students ran away and left behind the cheating materials. Here are some of the materials that my boys found.”
On a serious note, our police officers are sharp shooters and we know they are well trained for their work. And when they want they do their job well. I would not quite say the same about exam invigilation. I heard that in one school students carried setbook guides during a literature exam and when asked by the police officers what they were carrying, one student replied, “This is called a guide. You cannot sit a literature exam without it, the same way you cannot sit a mathematics exam without a mathematical table. And in a Chemistry practical exam, a police officer insulted and slapped a student for persistently asking for Silver Nitrate and the police officer told him there was no such a chemical as Silver Nitrate to be used in that exam and when the student pointed to a beaker written AgNO3, the officer was mad and said, “this is AgNO3, and not silver nitrate can’t you read!”
That’s why it is hard to say with surety that the KCSE Exam of 1998 was done without major irregularities. On one hand one would argue that no student however daring would trade their life at the altar of a good grade. In other words no student would cheat at the sight of a gun. On the other hand one would say that the police would never be able to effectively detect cheating in the exam.
In my High school, Wiyumiririe High School, the big issue was not the cheating in the examinations but the indiscipline that ensued following the teachers’ strike. At least we knew for the exam there was Kenya National Examinations Council to take care. And how they handled it was their problem. All students save the candidates were sent home during this period as was the case in virtually every school in the country. The candidates in our school chose to live a life of their own. They lived their life with no need of any program leaving them to do what they wished when they wished and how they wished. The school was in a state of anarchy and pretty funny incidents you see. One of them was the scramble and partition for food. Some students had to endure a week without tasting anything from the dining hall and relied on the school canteen for their stomach needs. Their colleagues would go in before them and take the food forcefully out of the dining hall to a place only them knew; not even caring to return the utensils to the dining hall. This was a trying time and even the coolest and most disciplined students found themselves putting all manners, all logic and rationality aside to survive in this complex jungle in the name of a school.
And soon there was a new habit in the school for the candidates. They even invented slogans like, “if you have it, you fought for it, you deserve it.” And they would keep asking each other;
“Man how was your day?”
And then an answer would come, “I have fought a good fight, I have finished the food, and I have kept the soup.” That was the answer of success. But there would always be the answer of desperation, “ Yea though I walk through the valley of the shadow of no food, I will fear no hunger.”
When the rest of us returned to school after the agreement between the government and the Kenya National Union of Teachers, we found our school in a pathetic state. Annoying scenes. Awful states in our dormitories with so many items missing. I was the new Captain of Kihaaro 1 dormitory and students streamed to my cubicle demanding that I do one thing or the other. It was so sickening and disheartening. Contrary to the saying of our elders that only those who leave something as they go find something upon their return, this time round those who left something found nothing upon their return.
I joined my fellow captains to the Principal’s office to report the menace.
The principal sympathized with the students but was non-committal on what the school would do about the issue. Actually as we left his office, we had nothing pretty to tell the students. All the school captain, Abel Mucheru would say to the students was, “well, my fellow students, you can be sure that Mr. Warutere is aware of this issue”
But when Mr. Kimemia an English Teacher reported that his goat was missing, the principal took the matter with more seriousness. Perhaps he knew if he doesn’t act, then his goat would be next. The goat disappeared the same day the rest of the school reported back but it must have been before we arrived and the loss was linked to the form fours.
So a very serious investigation began. There was no information available that could lead to the culprits of the goat scandal. But the investigations went on. And in a show of arrogance a number of candidates admitted to us that they had eaten the goat so the issue now was how to apprehend the masterminds.
The more we tried to investigate, the harder and complicated it was getting. The candidates ensured they plunge us into a world of contradiction and we were totally confused.
A neighbor to the school confirmed that he had seen some boys taking away the goat from where Mr. Kimemia had tethered it. The boys had warned him to mind his own business. Further investigations also revealed that the goat had been slaughtered in Kihaaro 1 Dormitory; my very own dormitory. So the school captain appointed a team of investigators consisting of high profile captains including myself. I was to head the team and Abel told me, “Chris, please make sure we drive to the depth of this matter” “ I will Abel”, that was my promise. So we started by checking in and around the dormitory. We did not get the slightest evidence that a goat had been slaughtered there. There was no smell of a goat not a trace of blood. This was becoming an enigma.
To widen the scope of the investigations, we had to assume that these candidates cooked the meat and they did not take it raw. Of course a goat is a small animal and wouldn’t be eaten by a very large group and so the beneficiaries of the delicacy must have as a matter of fact prepared the meat in a secluded place. This means we had to go around the school and have a look at some of the secret spots like common smoking spots and such like places. Of course we knew a fire in an open place would definitely leave traces that would be visible many days after. We found no such evidence and we were now giving up.
The matter was becoming complicated since some form fours actually told us the goat was cooked in the school kitchen during early morning hours.
This was becoming interesting and we went to the school kitchen and interrogated a few cooks and the cateress. There were no traces of meat having been cooked in any form in the kitchen save the meat that had been cooked for the whole form four class. The question was, did they roast it? Or did they boil it? Or did they fry it? There was no cooking fat unaccounted for according to the cateress so that would have ruled out frying but not so fast since they would have been smart enough to carry their own cooking fat. In fact whoever might have been involved must have been smart enough not to leave traces. And roasting? May be, but how without a single trace unless the one who did that had first sealed all loopholes including colluding with the night watchmen.
So we went back to Mr. Warutere with nothing tangible. All I told him was, Mr. Principal we have every reason to believe that that goat was slaughtered and eaten within the school. However, as for now, there is no actionable intelligence that could lead to the apprehension of those students who did that. And it might also be risky for us captains to continue in these investigations since those who did it are around and they are form fours and we are form threes. So I suggested that if there was need to carry on the investigations, perhaps teachers were better placed or an external team.
We left the principal’s office without having reached a consensus on the way forward and even after we tried to present the case for the students who had lost their property during this season, the principal simply told us that it was unfortunate students had to lose so much and the school will ensure that does not happen again in future. But the school according to him had no way to compensate the student since there was no such an expenditure vote in the school budget.
A week later we leant from reliable sources that Mr. Kimemia had been compensated by the school for the loss of his goat. This was so annoying since no student was compensated for what they lost. And all we could do is just wonder, “What kind of a society is this that has no justice for the small and lowly? Who cares for the common man down there? And why do crooks and criminals just do their thing and still continue smiling at us because we are too dumb or too weak or too unwilling to apprehend them? But most important, when will we ever enjoy the fruits of our labour and not have a few eat our goat?